I recently had the chance to try Antonio's for the first time, and overall it was a fairly average experience. The cheese was okay - not particularly impressive, but not terrible either. The sauce was decent, with a nice balance of sweetness and acidity. The slice I had was topped with a generous amount of herbs, which added some nice flavor and freshness. However, I did find the crust to be a bit dry, which took away from the overall enjoyment of the pie. On the plus side, the dining area at Antonio's was nice and comfortable, with plenty of seating and a welcoming atmosphere. Overall, I would say that Antonio's is a solid choice for a quick slice or pie, but it's not necessarily a destination spot for pizza lovers.

Best thin crust pizza in the Flemington area (I know it's a little far out, but sooooo worth the 15 minute drive)! They use fresh mushrooms vs the ones from the can!! So crunchy and flavorful!! Love i!!

This place is great. Ordered from Antonio's a few times. They are always willing to make an order to your liking. Tonight we ordered subs and a Stromboli. It's the Stromboli that propelled me to write because it was perfection. Crispy, filled with exactly how we ordered it. Veggies, garlic, light cheese, and anchovies....sublime! I can't wait to go back!

Best pizza I have had since Rays closed its doors at 11th street/6th avenue, in 1982. Thick rich cheese. Very fair price (2.50 with sausage)

I don't really write reviews but this place is so underrated. They recently opened a good two years ago and every Friday it's packed. Food is amazing and the pizza is something else here. The owner is very kind to the customers always trying his best to please them. His wife brings home made cookies and you can ask them to make specific ones. I come at least 3 times a week to eat here.

Their pizza is delicious and this place is a nice addition to the area. They also deliver. A must try!

I have been driving past this pizza place for well over a year without stopping in to try their offerings. That is, until I got pregnant. I am embarrassed to admit that I have sent my husband out three times within the last five days to grab me a plain slice of pizza from antonio's. What I'm not embarrassed to admit is their pizza is amazingly delicious. Nothing fancy, just the classic neighborhood pizza we all grew up with. The slices of pizza are a great value. For $2(tax included) you get a giant slice of pizza with a very generous layer of cheese. The plain slices are the only thing I have tried here, but if they are indicative of the rest of the menu, you will not be disappointed!